On October 03, Michigan officials announced that Canadian oil giant Enbridge will pay for the construction of a nearly 4-mile (6.4km) tunnel beneath the Straits of Mackinac to house a replacement for its controversial 65-year-old Line 5 pipeline.
The agreement with Republican governor Rick Snyder’s administration anticipates the excavation of a shared “utility corridor” through bedrock 100ft (30m) below the lake. The project is expected to take five years and cost in the region of $500 million.
The agreement will eventually eliminate “nearly every risk” of an oil leak into the Straits, Snyder said, while allowing for multiple utilities to share the tunnel, “better connecting our peninsulas, improving energy security and supporting economic development.”
Tunnelling Journal newsletter
The agreement depends upon separate negotiations between Enbridge and the Mackinac Bridge Authority – the state agency that oversees the suspension bridge traversing the straits near the underwater pipes – which the administration expects to be finalized before Snyder leaves office at the end of the year.
Although Enbridge’s feasibility study only assessed the possibility of housing the company’s own pipeline within the tunnel, Enbridge spokesman Ryan Duffy said the tunnel could be made bigger if officials decide to accommodate other utilities. Those details will be decided during the ongoing discussions with the Mackinac Bridge Authority.
The deal would “provide permanent protection for our Great Lakes” by separating the Line 5 oil pipeline from direct contact with the water, said Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Director Heidi Grether. She called it a “common-sense solution to a decades-long environmental concern.”
In the meantime, Enbridge will be required to take steps to reduce the risk of a spill as it continues to operate the aging Line 5, which carries up to 540,000 barrels a day of light crude oil and natural gas liquids from Wisconsin to Ontario, Canada, via the Great Lakes.
Michigan Environmental Council President and CEO Chris Kolb said the controversial deal leaves many unanswered questions about the fate of Line 5. “The tunnel will take years to build and during that time the risk of a spill from the existing 65-year-old pipeline poses a very serious threat,” he said in a statement. “At any moment, Line 5 could leak 2.4 million gallons of crude oil into the Great Lakes and cause billions of dollars of damage to our waters, coastal communities, and recreational economy.”
The agreement, reached as Snyder’s term winds down, is sure to be a contentious issue in the gubernatorial campaign to succeed him. Democratic nominee Gretchen Whitmer has pledged to shut down Line 5 if elected in November. Her Republican opponent, state Attorney General Bill Schuette, has endorsed the tunnel option.
The deal calls for negotiating a public-private partnership between the company and the Mackinac Bridge Authority. Enbridge would build the shared utility tunnel, transfer ownership to the authority and then lease it back for 99 years. While details are still being worked out, “the intent is for Enbridge to be responsible for the operation and maintenance of that tunnel,” said Michigan Department of Natural Resources Director Keith Creagh. If the Bridge Authority declines to be part of the deal, “it certainly would put this agreement relative to the tunnel aspects into question,” he said.