tunnelling-journal (1)
tunnelling-journal (1)
  • Home
  • Print
    • Subscribe
    • Tunnelling Journal
    • Breakthrough
    • ITA Activity Report
    • A&NZ Journal
    • WTC Preview
    • Media Kit
  • Digital
    • Newsletter
    • E-Shots
    • TJ Digital edition
    • Products Page
    • Media Kit
  • Conferences
    • BTS Conference and Exhibition
    • Cutting Edge 2022
  • Buyer’s Guide
  • Events Diary
  • Jobs
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Podcast

Home > Dr New warns of 'signature value' at the BTS Harding Lecture

Dr New warns of 'signature value' at the BTS Harding Lecture

Tris Thomas

Written by Tris Thomas on 23/01/2017 in News

Tagged:

Senior consultants and engineers should stop putting their names to documents that they have not reviewed, said Dr Barry New of Geotechnical Consulting Group at this year’s British Tunnelling Society Harding Memorial Lecture.Presenting on Thursday 19th January, New called on managing engineers to “value your signature”, explaining that many of the reports he received on behalf of utility clients had clearly been written by junior engineers and were not up to scratch.  “Those people acting as checkers and approvers cannot possibly have read the reports they have signed,” said New. “It’s something I understand, but I don’t like it.”

New’s characteristically direct approach had already been applauded by Professor Lord Robert Mair who  introduced New to a packed audience at the Institution of Civil Engineers in Westminster, with some attendees watching via a screen in a second room. Mair, who has known New for over 40 years, praised “his willingness to cut to the chase and call a spade a spade”, as well as his contributions to our understanding of how tunnelling projects impact on existing tunnels and pipelines.

The subject of the lecture was ‘Tunnelling Impact Assessment for Utility Pipelines and Tunnels’, which New addressed through a combination of dry observations, photos and anecdotes. Along the way, he called into question commercial awards ceremonies that are focussed on revenue rather than excellence and conferences which accept too many papers of insufficient quality, again for financial gain.

At the heart of the lecture, which will be followed by a more technical paper, is New’s proposal that we need a new approach to risk assessment for utilities. The current practice of assuming a number of between 1 and 5 for the likelihood of something happening and the consequence of it happening and then multiplying the two numbers, is meaningless, he suggested. Photographs of a confusion of services, propped off each other and build round each other illustrated his point.

New’s alternative approach is a risk-based analysis which he outlined in four steps. First, look at the maintenance and report history of a section of tunnel or pipeline to get an understanding of its condition; second, determine its strategic importance; then design protection measures, diversions or replacement depending on the significance of the asset; and finally formulate a rescue and repair plan and ensure that the resources to do it are on site and ready to go.

Comments:

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

Digital Edition

More Like This

08/03/2023

Macau’s first EPBM breaks through

Macau’s first EPBM breaks through

February 20th, 2023 saw Macau’s first small diameter EPBM “CREC 1076” breaking through, laying a solid foundation for the timely…

16/02/2023

UYAK2023 postponed to June 5-6-7, 2023

UYAK2023 postponed to June 5-6-7, 2023

Due to the devastating earthquake in Turkey, the UYAK2023 5th International Underground Excavations Symposium & Exhibition planned in March, has…

20/02/2023

Slurry TBM launched on TWRP Contract 1 in Singapore

Slurry TBM launched on TWRP Contract 1 in Singapore

February 1st saw the launch of the CRCHI Slurry TBM ‘Channel Express’ that will now bore the 1.6km, 6m i.d undersea…

  • Contact Us
  • Media Kit
  • Magazine Archive

Newsletter

The latest from the Tunneling Journal direct to your inbox.

Social



Enquiries

TGS Media Ltd
The Old Library
Webster House
Dudley Road
Tunbridge Wells
TN1 1LE
United Kingdom

© Tunnelling Journal. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy / Terms & Conditions. Admin

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkRead more