tunnelling-journal (1)
tunnelling-journal (1)
  • Home
  • Print
    • Subscribe
    • Tunnelling Journal
    • Breakthrough
    • ITA Activity Report
    • A&NZ Journal
    • WTC Preview
    • Media Kit
  • Digital
    • Newsletter
    • E-Shots
    • TJ Digital edition
    • Products Page
    • Media Kit
  • Conferences
    • BTS Conference and Exhibition
    • Cutting Edge 2022
  • Buyer’s Guide
  • Events Diary
  • Jobs
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Podcast

Home > High Court hearing granted to Stonehenge challenge

High Court hearing granted to Stonehenge challenge

Tris Thomas

Written by Tris Thomas on 18/02/2021 in News

Tagged: Stonehenge Tunnel

UK campaigner group, Save Stonehenge World Heritage Site (SSWHS), has secured a hearing in their judicial review challenge on the decision to allow a new A303 dual carriageway and tunnel that it believes would cause significant harm to the Stonehenge World Heritage Site (WHS).

A High Court judge has decided that legal arguments, concerning the UK’s Transport Secretary Grant Shapps’ decision to allow the 12.8km long road project with a 3.2km long tunnel past Stonehenge, must be dealt with at a “rolled up” hearing at which the Court will decide both whether the claim is arguable and, if so, whether it succeeds.

Now the claim by SSWHS, a group of individual supporters of the Stonehenge Alliance, will proceed to a hearing at the High Court in a matter of months. There will be a preliminary hearing next week to set the timetable for that process.

If the Court ultimately rules that Mr Shapps’ decision was unlawful, he will have to rethink the controversial road project. SSWHS says in a statement that permission for the scheme was granted against the advice of the Examining Authority (ExA), a five-person panel of expert inspectors, who examined the application by Highways England for the Amesbury to Berwick Down draft Development Consent Order under section 37 of the Planning Act 2008.

The inspectors said the scheme, with deep cuttings and tunnel entrances within the WHS, would permanently harm the integrity of the WHS and seriously harm its authenticity. It is argued that the scheme is also contrary to the Wiltshire Core Strategy and the requirements of the World Heritage Convention.

Mr Shapps agreed with the ExA that the development will harm visual and spatial relationships and settings in the ancient landscape of the World Heritage Site but concluded that the level of harm would not be substantial and would be outweighed by the public benefit.

At the public examination, the Stonehenge Alliance and a number of other parties argued that the World Heritage Site ought to be protected in its entirety. However, Mr Shapps is reportedly satisfied the Development has been designed to accord with the National Planning Policy Statement for National Networks (NPSNN) and that reasonable mitigation has been included to minimise harm to the landscape.

The Stonehenge site was declared by the World Heritage Committee (WHC) to be of Outstanding Universal Value (OUV) in 1986. Owing to its remarkable complex of prehistoric monuments and sites it is considered to be a “landscape without parallel”.

SSWHS says that an alternative plan for the road, namely a longer tunnel that would cause less harm, was not considered by Mr Shapps.

 

Comments:

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

Digital Edition

More Like This

09/12/2022

ITA Tunnelling and Underground Space Awards winners announced

ITA Tunnelling and Underground Space Awards winners announced

The 8th Edition of the ITA Tunnelling and Underground Space Awards ended yesterday with the winners in the eight categories…

23/09/2022

First Breakthrough on Italy’s Lonato Railway Tunnel

First Breakthrough on Italy’s Lonato Railway Tunnel

China’s first TBM exported to Italy – a CREC 699 10.03m diameter machine designed and manufactured by China Railway Engineering…

14/02/2023

Contracts awarded for Toulouse Metro Line C

Contracts awarded for Toulouse Metro Line C

Tisséo, the public transport authority for Greater Toulouse have awarded two significant contracts for Line C of the Toulouse Metro….

  • Contact Us
  • Media Kit
  • Magazine Archive

Newsletter

The latest from the Tunneling Journal direct to your inbox.

Social



Enquiries

TGS Media Ltd
The Old Library
Webster House
Dudley Road
Tunbridge Wells
TN1 1LE
United Kingdom

© Tunnelling Journal. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy / Terms & Conditions. Admin

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkRead more